List of incumbents
Last Updated (Saturday, 20 June 2009 12:30)
| Years at St Nicolas | Incumbent |
| 1292 | John of London, Rector Resigned, the Rectory passing to Chertsey Abbey |
| Vicars | |
| 1314 | William of Sutton |
| William of Geddynge | |
| 1320 | Geoffrey of Sutton |
| 1324 | Thomas le Blount |
| 1349 | Richard le Blount |
| 1349 | Richard Palmere |
| William of Blaston | |
| 1365 | Richard atte Mulle |
| 1378 | William Spenser |
| 1381 | William Clerke |
| 1395 | John Coupere |
| 1413 | Henry Stampard |
| John Wodecroft | |
| 1449 | John Newman |
| 1463 | Robert Browne |
| 1467 | William Rede |
| William Pye | |
| 1472 | John Curteys |
| 1475 | Thomas Rydynge |
| 1477 | Geoffrey Matthews |
| William Bradock | |
| 1507 | John Hurt |
| 1524 | John Cottisford, DD |
| 1527 | Thomas Smyth |
| 1530 | Fulk Symonds |
| 1543 | John Hylton |
| 1561 | Matthew Standley |
| 1581 | Thomas Ellys |
| 1584 | John Reeve, DD |
| 1620 | Samuel Cherrie, MA |
| c1657 | Richard Carter |
| 1661 | Henry Barrett |
| John Flemminge | |
| 1668 | John Hyet, MA |
| 1728 | Samuel L'Isle |
| 1737 | Reeve Ballard, DD |
| 1769 -1809 | Samuel Cooke, MA |
| 1809 -1820 | Gerrard Andrewes, DD |
| Rectors | |
| Jan 1821 - 1879 | William Heberden, MA |
| 1880 | Edward Malleson, MA |
| 1899 -1905 | George Shepheard Bird, MA |
| 1917 -1926 | Walter Norman Higgins, MA |
| 1934 | Alec Manston Hughes, MA |
| 1965 | Maurice Furlonger, AKC |
| 1967 | Jonathan Gilbert Edwards, MA |
| 1980 | Andrew Compton Warner, MA |
| 2001 - 2007 | Penny Fleming |
| 2007 | Alan Jenkins |